WA Case Update: What Amounts will the Court Consider When Comparing an Arbitration Award and a Trial Judgment?

From the desk of Kyle D. Riley: Is the court permitted to consider post-arbitration costs to determine whether a party requesting a trial de novo improved their position at trial? Read on to find out how the Washington Court of Appeals recently answered this question.

Claims Pointer: The Washington Court of Appeals held that the trial court was incorrect in awarding attorney fees when the trial judgment was more favorable to the party seeking a trial de novo, before including post-arbitration costs. This case provides an important overview of how the court will compare an arbitration award and a trial judgment for purposes of deciding whether a party is entitled to attorney fees.

Bearden v. McGill, No. 72926-8-I, Washington Court of Appeals, Div. I. (April 11, 2016).

James Bearden (Bearden) sued Dolphus McGill (McGill) for damages caused by an auto accident. An arbitrator awarded Bearden $44,000 in compensatory damages and $1,187 in statutory costs, for a total arbitration award of $45,187. McGill requested a trial de novo. The jury awarded Bearden less in compensatory damages, ($42,500) but the trial court awarded more in costs, ($3,296.39) which included costs incurred after arbitration, for a total judgment of $45,796.39. When a party appeals an arbitration award and requests a trial de novo, that party will be obligated to pay costs and reasonable attorney fees if the party fails to improve its position. After comparing the arbitration award and the trial judgment, the trial court held that McGill failed to improve his position and awarded Bearden $71,800 in attorney fees.

The Washington Court of Appeals reversed this decision, holding that McGill did indeed improve his position at trial. In order to determine if a party improved its position at trial, the court should compare the aggregate success on claims actually litigated between the parties at both the arbitration and trial de novo. In this case, the trial court awarded Bearden fees and costs not...

To View the Full Resource, Subscribe or Log In